What’s the Difference Between Payroll Tax and Income Tax?

/ Accounting, Business Tax, Financial Services, Payroll, Tax Planning / By

What’s the Difference Between Payroll Tax and Income Tax?

If you’ve ever looked at your paycheck (or handled payroll as a business owner), you’ve probably seen deductions for both payroll tax and income tax. At first glance, they might seem like the same thing—but they’re actually two very different parts of the tax system.

Understanding what the difference between payroll and income tax really comes down to who pays what, how it’s calculated, and where the money ends up. Whether you’re running a business or just want to make more sense of your pay stub, knowing how each tax works can help you avoid headaches—and potentially save money in the long run.

So, What’s the Difference Between Payroll and Income Tax?

Here’s the short version:

  • Payroll tax helps fund specific programs like Social Security and Medicare. It’s split between the employer and employee.
  • Income tax is based on a person’s total earnings and is paid only by the employee. This tax goes toward broader government funding—things like schools, roads, and defense.

In other words, payroll tax is more focused and shared, while income tax is broader and based entirely on the employee’s financial situation.

Breaking Down the Basics

What Is Payroll Tax?

Payroll tax is withheld from an employee’s wages and matched (in part) by the employer. These taxes go straight toward programs like:

  • Social Security
  • Medicare
  • Federal Unemployment (FUTA)
  • State Unemployment (SUTA)

For Social Security and Medicare, both the employee and employer chip in—each pays 6.2% for Social Security and 1.45% for Medicare. FUTA and SUTA, on the other hand, are typically paid by the employer alone and help fund unemployment benefits.

These are usually flat-rate taxes, meaning the percentage stays the same regardless of income (though there are annual wage limits).

What Is Income Tax?

Income tax is based on how much someone earns in total. Employers withhold this tax from each paycheck and send it to the IRS on the employee’s behalf. The amount withheld depends on things like:

  • How much the employee makes
  • Their filing status (single, married, head of household, etc.)
  • What they filled out on their W-4 form

Unlike payroll taxes, income tax is not matched by the employer—employees are responsible for it entirely, though the employer handles the withholding and remittance.

What Is the Difference Between Payroll and Income Tax? A Closer Look

Who’s Paying?

  • Payroll tax is a joint effort—both employer and employee pay a portion.
  • Income tax is paid only by the employee, though the employer handles the paperwork.

What Do They Support?

  • Payroll taxes go directly to things like Social Security, Medicare, and unemployment insurance.
  • Income taxes cover a wide range of federal and state services—everything from national defense to public schools.

How Are They Calculated?

  • Payroll tax is calculated using fixed percentages of gross wages.
  • Income tax is more complex, using a tiered system with tax brackets, credits, deductions, and other factors that change based on individual circumstances.

These differences affect not just take-home pay, but also how businesses manage payroll and year-end tax reporting.

What This Means for Employers and Employees

For Employers

As an employer, you’re on the hook for a few things:

  • Withholding payroll and income taxes from every paycheck
  • Matching the required share of payroll taxes
  • Filing the proper forms (like IRS Form 941) each quarter
  • Sending payments to the IRS and state tax agencies on time

Missing a deadline—or underpaying—can lead to penalties or even an audit. That’s why a solid payroll system and a proactive CPA are key for small businesses.

For Employees

For employees, the impact shows up in your net pay:

  • Payroll tax contributions help fund your future benefits (like retirement or disability coverage).
  • Income tax depends on your financial picture and gets sorted out when you file your annual return—either you get a refund, or you owe a bit more.

Understanding how your taxes are withheld helps you plan better, avoid surprises in April, and adjust your W-4 when your situation changes.

Why This Matters for Small Business Owners

The line between payroll tax and income tax may seem minor, but getting it wrong can cause big problems. If you misclassify, under-report, or miss a deposit deadline, the IRS may charge penalties—and they’re not always small.

Many small business owners rely on payroll software or bookkeepers, but even then, mistakes can slip through. Working with a CPA in Columbus who understands payroll compliance and IRS reporting requirements helps you catch issues before they snowball.

Plus, staying on top of both payroll and income taxes means smoother audits, better cash flow, and fewer surprises.

Common Questions We Hear

Are payroll taxes deductible for employers?
 Yes. The employer-paid portion of payroll taxes (like Social Security and Medicare matches) can be deducted as a business expense.

If I’m self-employed, do I pay both payroll and income taxes?
 In a way, yes. Self-employed people pay self-employment tax, which covers both the employer and employee sides of Social Security and Medicare, plus regular income tax.

What happens if I file payroll or income taxes late?
 You could face penalties, interest, or even collection actions from the IRS. It’s not worth the risk—accuracy and timeliness are key.

Want Help Navigating Payroll and Income Taxes?

Whether you’re just starting out or already managing a growing team, it pays to understand the difference between payroll and income tax—and to get it right.

At Hogan CPA Financial Services, we work with business owners across Columbus to take the stress out of payroll, tax filings, and IRS compliance. We’ll help you stay organized, minimize risk, and keep your business running smoothly.

Let’s talk about how we can support your business—reach out today for personalized guidance.

Need Help Managing Income Taxes?

Getting payroll and income taxes right isn’t just about compliance—it’s about protecting your business and your team. At Hogan CPA Financial Services, we help businesses across Columbus and the US streamline their business, stay IRS-compliant, and minimize tax liability.

Contact us today to get expert help with payroll processing, income tax filing, and full-service accounting support tailored to your business.